amw (amw) wrote,

  • Mood:

the bubble is popping

The best thing about the last week of coronavirus coverage is that some people in the west have gotten over their initial panic and are starting to write critically about the response.

My favorite article of the past week was in the Journal of Medical Ethics blog: The vital contexts of coronavirus.

Money quote: Take Scotland: here, the death rate had averaged between 6 and 8 people per day before increasing to 16 on the 1st of April. But the typical death rate in Scotland is 160 people per day, with about a quarter of them dying of cancer. This means that the virus is currently increasing the daily rate by 10% (and before that around 5%) – a substantial increase, but not as massive as many members of the public are probably assuming, given the press coverage. Reporting the increasing number of deaths in isolation without this context is likely to increase people's stress about the virus, because people are unaware of how many people normally die each day.

This is the one thing i wish most that the media would change about their coverage. Stop putting this arbitrary number of cases front and center. Give people the context to understand the problem by comparing actual hospital admissions and deaths to the baseline.

Obviously this virus is much worse than a normal cold or flu. However, seeing it in relation to other massive killers makes it easier for me to conceptualize. The worst case scenarios say tens of millions could die around the world - similar to the Spanish Flu outbreak of 1918. That would be terrible. But it also would still "only" be twice as many people dying around the world as normal for a year. This isn't an extinction event. Humankind will prevail.

I lost my mother to cancer last year. My godfather died of cancer a while back, as did my sister's godmother and one of my aunts. Three of my grandparents have passed away. My closest friend committed suicide. Several other friends have also taken their own lives, or died from a drug overdose. People around me die, maybe one every couple years. So the odds are that someone around me will die this year. One of my friends in the UK already got the corona. He recovered. Others will get it and may not. I could get it and may not.

I don't want to die, but i also don't want to remain trapped in one country, unable to quit or move, while tens or hundreds of millions around the world lose their jobs, their incomes, their schooling, their ways of life. And i really don't want to live in a world that chooses to come out the other end of this like China did - with notably heightened xenophobia and a retreat to the comforting embrace of authoritarianism.

While there were some people in the anarchist and libertarian worlds that complained about this stuff from day one, the past week has thankfully seen more opinion pieces coming from the political mainstream that also face the reality of what these lockdown policies have done to society. People are starting to cotton on to how bourgeois a mass lockdown policy is.

As expected, lockdown means many blue and pink collar people lose their jobs immediately while most white collar people continue to collect a salary and work from home. I am still waiting for the day when the headline is not "coronavirus puts 6 million out of work" and is instead more accurately expressed as "government lockdown puts 6 million out of work" or "employers lay off 6 million working class people".

People who can afford property enjoy the fresh air and space of their back yard or balcony while those of less means are cooped up in cramped apartments or share accommodation. In places where going outside for a walk has been banned, the disparity is compounded. Even where going outside hasn't been banned, the hysterical masses have supported police and private security engaging in brutal enforcement, often targeting the poor.

Here is Edward Santow, Australia's human rights commissioner with an opinion piece in the Guardian: We must combat Covid-19 but creeping authoritarianism could do more harm than good.

Meanwhile, to get everyone over the hump, the government suddenly finds buckets of money that for years they claimed weren't available when it came to using them to pay for other social welfare programs. Naturally, big business is enjoying the spoils already, while the newly-unemployed still wait for their cut to trickle down.

Matt Stoller wrote about the challenges getting money to the people yesterday in his newsletter: The Cantillon Effect: Why Wall Street Gets a Bailout and You Don't.

Extract: [Cantillon's] basic theory was that who benefits when the state prints a bunch of money is based on the institutional setup of that state. In the 18th century, this meant that the closer you were to the king and the wealthy, the more you benefitted, and the further away you were, the more you were harmed. Money, in other words, is not neutral.

Aside from lockdowns, the other outrageous policy the whole world is living with right now is closed borders. Here in China we're dealing with it on the micro level - all neighborhoods are still fenced in and closed off to outsiders - but countries everywhere have effectively shut down their national borders. This is some kind of medieval bullshit that goes against everything i hold dear. It's like Brexit++, further stripping me of my identity as a human, a migrant, a wanderer, and not a citizen of any particular state.

But the assault on my identity is a first world problem compared to all the actual refugees, economic migrants and stateless folks caught up in the middle of this mess. The UNHCR is reporting on their plight: Live blog: Refugees in the COVID-19 crisis. It can tend a bit toward fluffy feel-good stories, but they post links to harder hitting reporting too.

Anyway, it's Friday morning for me and i am staying home so that i have time to do grocery shopping. The supermarket's restricted hours during lockdown have been lifted, but it still closes early at 8pm which means i don't have time to shop after work. After posting this i will walk around to my village checkpoint and then loop back to the wet market near my house to get some supplies. Then do the whole loop in reverse, come home, brew coffee and jump onto Outlook and Zoom and Slack to do my last day of work shit before the weekend.

My life is not too bad right now, relatively speaking. I've spent 2+ months keeping my head down and doing everything the government told me to do. I've done my bit for flattening the curve. Doesn't mean i'm not still upset about it all.
Tags: news, politics
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.